Into The Dark Timeline

Warning: This contains spoilers

This page is to give people a clear timeline of events of the albums.

Characters

 * Kathryn
 * Katie
 * Angela
 * Michael
 * Amber
 * Enjolie
 * Emma
 * Lily

Into The Dark

 * Empty: Kathryn talks about how she feels empty with nothing around. This is from the future when everything is over and she is in the afterlife without her friends. She also compares herself to a empty bottle you knock over and break, this shows she is very breakable.
 * Afraid: This song is also from the future Katie is afraid of loneliness but her grandpa wants to be alone.
 * Lost: Kathryn talks about getting lost in her crushes eyes.
 * Fun Forever: This song is from the present as Kathryn is having fun with her friends and remembering all the good things that happened. Angela appears here so she had been friends with Kathryn and Katie before her death
 * Into The Dark: A unknown girl who went into the dark side and never came back.
 * Take The Blame: Kathryn's ex friend who never says sorry or takes the blame and blames it on her instead. Kathryn expresses that you need to own up to your mistakes.
 * Say Sorry: Kathryn talks about how saying sorry will help out in the long run.
 * Socialize: Kathryn talks about being anti-social and how society should normalize not being able to talk to people.
 * Trust Issues: While the song talks about Kathryn having trust issues. In the music video Kathryn is pushed off the boat by her ex friend Trixie, she gets boiled alive by witches. Amber saves her but it's too late and she dies but Kathryn's ghost saves Amber from the witches and sends her back to her friends. Although as the boat floats away Kathryn is seen on the boat, that is her soul following her friends. Her soul disappears because her job is done. The dove is symbolism for her dying peacefully even though she was boiled by witches.
 * Angela: This song is from the past as a friend of Angela named Emma reminiscences on the night Angela went missing as she went out with her. Angela was being a rebel, going out to parties which is later mentioned in Alethophobia and when she got home Michael forced her to kill herself. She talks about not wanting to end up like Angela because of what happened to her.

Before The Sun Sets

 * Lily: Angela lives in a apartment now that she moved away from her parents house. She still remembers Lily's death, calls Kathryn, and hallucinates Lily being there until she reaches the hotel. Kathryn's ghost was there the whole time but she was halluncinating Lily and Kathryn was not gonna tell her that Lily was not actually there.
 * How Life Goes: Katie leaves her Grandpa's house and goes to a orphanage where she still thinks about all the times but knows life is a game and she will have to keep living it.
 * Nothing Left But Us: Talia and Emma become friends with Angela and keep encouraging her on after learning about Lily's death.
 * Love At First Sight: Angela falls in love with Michael and moves into his apartment.
 * Alethophobia: Michael suddenly acts different when Angela gets to know him, he doesn't let her do things she wants to do and becomes overprotective.
 * Save Your Life: Angela becomes depressed because of what is going on, she tells everyone but they only tell her to go to therapy.
 * Empty Skies: Katie gets adopted by Jada and as she drives her to her new home, Katie thinks about her feelings and how she can't hide them.
 * Time To Go: After Angela's death Talia and Emma have to get over it.
 * Come And Find Me: Katie and Emma talk to each other telepathically and try to find someone who is going through a death of a loved one like them.
 * Before The Sun Sets: Kathryn talks as if everything is over she tells Katie, Jada, Talia, and Emma everything is alright and to come before the sun sets to show them something. She shows them the afterlife and they live happily. she tells them that everything is just how they wanted it, meaning she created what they wanted in heaven and invited them in.

Theories

 * Into The Dark is possibly another perspective of Angela's death
 * Take The Blame could have been about Trixie
 * There is most likely not going to be a ITD3